Have I Got News For You

HIGNFY 27 October 2010

Picture by Jon Large used under terms of Creative Commons Licence

This evening’s episode of the BBC program Have I Got News For You was, in my opinion, not as funny as it usually is. I’m a big fan, and have watched for many years. I remember Paul Merton winning when his team-mate was a tub of lard. I remember when Merton & Ian Hislop gave Angus Deaton a roasting over his behaviour shortly before he left the show. I like the satirical take on the weeks events, the guest publication and the caption competition.

And this evenings episode looked all set to be a good one. Clare Balding was presenting, Graham Linehan & Ken Livingstone were guests – all sounds promising. And it started well, mocking Tory party conference in the usual style, replaying the clip of George Osbourne being booed at the Paralympics. And then the show took a turn that cannot have been easy to navigate through – Jimmy Saville. It’s been the biggest story of the week, they could hardly leave it alone. Now I’m guessing the show is filmed a few days in advance, because there was no mention of the headstone being removed. And it became a space to vent, not about the horrors of what he is alleged to have done, but also of the way the wider media have responded in particular to the BBC where rumours it seems were rife, yet nothing was done, or even said, officially. This section of the program was light on jokes, but the few that there were were close cutting – Graham Linehan suggested that all the Jim’ll Fix It badges be collected up and melted into a stake to be driven through his grave (and has already had offers on Twitter of badges to get him started).

Saville cannot be held to account for his actions, but the climate now is so different. In my work I know that rumour can be so dangerous, particularly in child protection issues, but I hope that if there are lessons to be learned they can be – but I hope things are already in place to stop such a thing happening again.

Clare Balding’s remarks about the Daily Mail were spot on, and I hope it makes some people think about there choice of news outlet. It is not acceptable to me to print pictures of teenagers in bikinis then be outraged by paedophiles.

I thought the Abu-Hamza joke was in poor taste.

So I’ll tune in again next week – I might even check out Have I Got a Bit More News for You to see what was cut.

#oneaday, day 24, football pundits

So I understand some Sky football pundits left their mics on and ‘joked’ that a female assistant referee didn’t know the off side rule. It turns out that she had in fact made an excellent call, and the pundits were dropped from tonights coverage and given a stiff telling off. Or something.

Now it is obvious that sexist remarks have no place in society, and that anyone should be able to be what they want regardless of gender. However, I think this event has given us a larger question to consider – why do we need pundits?

For example, when watching football, I want to hear John Motson commentate. The man has been doing this since he was a boy, and seems to recall every game he has ever watched. Like referees, a professional.

Then along comes someone who used to play and at half time gives us ‘analysis’. To what end? Mostly they just seem to disagree or try and say something controversial. And are often wrong.

So let’s have more professional analysis please, and leave former footballers to advertise snack foods, supermarkets and to dance. Ice optional.